The Best Piggy Banks for Kids – (NEW 2019 Edition)
The venerable piggy bank is a gift that children may not fully appreciate until they are much older. When piggy banks are used as learning opportunities, they can teach prudent financial habits.
But, if piggy banks are used as a temporary slush fund, the lesson of responsibility is lost.
So, which piggy bank is the right one for your child or loved one? In this article, we’ll dive into the world of piggy banking to show you which piggy banks will make you squeal with delight and which will leave you wallowing.
We’ll also give you a handful of tips regarding how to use the piggy bank as a learning opportunity for your loved one — and how to encourage the financial habits that will sustain them for life.
Piggy Bank Reviews
Our #1 Choice – Baseball Shape Piggy Bank for Saving Money and Sports Room Decor
The is baseball-style piggy bank is simple, has a large capacity, and has a convenient stopper located at the bottom to ensure that you don’t need to break the bank to make a withdrawal.
- Great for sports lovers
- Can take bills and also coins
- Attractive aesthetic
- May smash if accidentally knocked to the floor
The trick to getting your child to love their piggy bank is making it into one of their favorite decorations. This baseball-shaped piggy bank does exactly that, meaning that if your child loves baseball they’ll love to display and contribute to their decorative fund.
When it’s time to make a withdrawal, there’s a convenient stopper at the bottom of the ball. The only issue is that the stopper is easy to remove and replace.
This means that your young baseball fanatic could make a deposit into the piggy bank one day, and then make a withdrawal on the next day. The lesson of careful saving — and reducing frivolous spending — needs to be heavily reinforced if you opt to use this piggy bank.
Our #2 Choice – Carters Smiley Happy Piggy Bank
The Carters Smiley Happy Piggy Bank is the prototypical piggy bank thanks to its silver ceramic appearance, coin-slot style deposit hole, and a lack of convenient withdrawal features.
- Cute piggy shape
- Satisfying coin clink noise upon deposit
- Must be broken to withdraw savings
- Difficult to fit bills into the coin slot
If you’re looking for a no-frills piggy bank that looks good and has all of the features you expect from a piggy bank — and not one more — it’s hard to find a better piggy bank than this Carters Smiley Happy Piggy Bank.
Every time your child drops a coin into the slot, they’ll be delighted by the sound of money reverberating from inside the piggy’s belly. Unfortunately, your child will struggle to cram bills into the coin slot, so this piggy bank is best for pocket change rather than genuine savings.
When the piggy bank is full and it’s time to make a withdrawal, there’s only one way out: the ceremonial piggy bank smash. The beautiful ceramic pigskin must be destroyed to access the savings within.
This means that you’ll need to purchase another piggy bank to replace this one if you have a particularly studious saver.
On the other hand, the smashing of the piggy bank is something that many modern piggy banks lack — so the significance of breaking into savings will be even more solemn and educational.
Our #3 Choice – Itazura New Pokemon-Go inspired Electronic Coin Money Piggy Bank
For Pokemon lovers, this Itazura Pikachu piggy bank is a great way of combining the cutest pokemon with sound financial education.
- Fun Pokemon-themed design
- Pikachu reacts in response to deposits
- Great for coins
- Requires batteries
- Small capacity
Whenever your child pops a coin onto the poke-pad, they’ll be delighted by Pikachu’s perky and positive response. Especially for younger children who love Pokemon, getting the positive reinforcement from Pikachu can be a great way of building a good habit.
For the parents in the audience, the Pikachu piggy bank will require batteries the more frequently that your child makes deposits.
So, while you may be inconvenienced by the need to provide batteries to the piggy bank, if you need to buy batteries it’s a good sign that your young Pokemon trainer is enthusiastic about packing away a lot of coins to save for later.
The only issue with this piggy bank is that it isn’t capable of accepting bills. So, you may need a secondary piggy bank for teaching your child how to save money in larger denominations.
Our #4 Choice – Reed & Barton Classic Piggy Bank
When you want the classic piggy bank look without the hassle of cleaning up a smashed piggy after making a withdrawal, the Reed and Barton Classic Piggy Bank is a suave and functional gift for your special saver.
- Realistic pig shape
- Difficult but accessible withdrawal
- Doubles as a toy
- Silver plate may scratch or melt
This piggy bank is made from real tarnish-proof silver, which means that it is a bigger investment than most other piggy banks intended for children. Nonetheless, the piggy bank’s high-quality means that your child could carry it with them for the rest of their life.
Indeed, the piggy bank has a lifetime warranty, and it is very sturdy. The only way that it will be damaged is by getting scratched or melted by a fire. So, if you give it to your child when they are very young, it may have a few scars by the time they’ve made a few withdrawals.
The withdrawal mechanism of this piggy bank is a simple cork plug in the bottom of the piggy. The force required to turn the cork plug is significant, so your child probably won’t be able to remove it on their own until they are at least 10 years old.
Over all, this piggy bank is very close to the ideal form of piggy banks, so it’s a great choice.
Our #5 Choice – Tooarts Owl Shaped Metal Coin Bank Box
For a cheerful avian spin on the piggy bank concept, the Tooarts Owl piggy bank is an obvious pickup.
- Doubles as a candle holder
- Coins may fall out when the owl is moved
With this owl-shaped piggy bank, children who love birds will be delighted. The beautiful handcrafted mesh also gives everyone an indication of how much money is stored in the owl’s belly.
Furthermore, the owl is large enough for a very substantial amount of money, especially if your child makes contributions in bills.
The problem with the owl’s meshing is that small coins like dimes and pennies are apt to fall right through the mesh if they happen to be jostled into a vertical position. So, for a piggy bank that will stay stationary nearly all the time, the owl poses no issues.
But, for children who prefer to play with their piggy bank and hear the change rattling around inside, the owl is a recipe for throwing coins all over the ground.
Unfortunately, there isn’t any way to address this issue, so you may find that another piggy bank is better for children who prefer active play with their savings instruments.
Our #6 Choice – Beginnings by Enesco Big Polka Dot Piggy Bank
For a cheerful and standard piggy bank, the Enesco Polka Dot Piggy Bank is sure to please your child.
- Blue and green polka dot design
- Tall and heavy with high capacity
- Durable build quality appropriate for all ages
- Size may be awkward for younger children
With this piggy bank, your loved one gets an attractive ornament for their room while also getting the change to save up a lot of their loose coins.
Much like with other traditional-style piggy banks, this piggy bank must be broken to make a withdrawal. In other words, you’ll need to have a vacuum handy to pick up the tiny pieces of porcelain that may result from a suboptimal shattering.
On the bright side, the piggy bank is designed to fracture cleanly in response to a sharp force. So, when you and your loved one and ready to withdraw their hard-earned cash, you can hit the bank with a mallet and see it crumble in one satisfying swoop.
Our #7 Choice – DEMDACO Piggy Bank, Blue Whale
The DEMDACO piggy bank is a gorgeous gift for any child who loves marine life or nautical-themed things.
- Cheerful two-tone blue whale style
- Great for young babies
- Surprisingly large capacity
- Minimal play value due to awkward shape
Blue whales are huge, and this whale piggy bank has a lot of room in its belly — or perhaps in its head, given the location of the coin slot. The simple and cheerful color scheme of this piggy bank make it a great choice for any nautical room or playset.
Likewise, children who appreciate sea creatures are sure to cherish their contributions to this blue whale. The only issue is that withdrawing coins from the whale will be traumatic for the whale.
There’s no way to remove coins from this cheerful blue whale aside from smashing it, which will probably disturb everyone in the family.
So, it is probably better to give this blue whale piggy bank to very young children as a gift with the understanding that it is better to avoid cashing out the money within.
Our #8 Choice – Burton & Burton Girls Pink & Green Circles Pig Piggy Bank
Adding a green bow to the timeless piggy bank design makes this piggy bank even more cute than you would expect.
- Easy to personalize with a dry erase marker
- Satin green ribbon detaches for use as an accessory
- Fun design appropriate for young boys and girls
- Hard to wash off any dry erase marker comments
The twist with this piggy bank is that you can customize the piggy bank’s white exterior using a dry erase marker so that your loved one will see your unique contribution to their savings vehicle whenever they make a deposit.
This means that this piggy bank is a great way to leave sentimental messages for your child that they will read and appreciate when they are older.
Aside from the customizability of this piggy bank, your loved one can also detach the green ribbon on the piggy’s head and use it on their hair or their clothing. While the piggy looks a little sparse without its signature ribbon, you can replace it at your leisure.
Piggy Bank FAQ
What should I look for in a piggy bank?
There are a few features you should look for in a piggy bank. These features include:
- Accepting both coins and bills
- Good aesthetics
- Having a large capacity
Of these features, having a large capacity is less important than being aesthetically pleasing and accepting both coins and bills. Your child will make more contributions to their piggy bank if they can put whatever extra money they have into the bank’s slot.
This means that if they need to store their bills somewhere else, they’re much less likely to save. Likewise, if your child doesn’t like the look of their piggy bank, they’re less likely to make contributions.
If they really dislike the look of their piggy bank, they may build a negative association between making deposits into the piggy bank and saving money. So, ensure that the piggy bank you purchase for your child is something that you know they already enjoy.
It’s also preferable to find a piggy bank that has a high capacity because it will encourage your child to save more before making a withdrawal. The more they save before making a withdrawal, the more impressed they’ll be with the results of their efforts.
Thus, while the capacity of the piggy bank is important, it isn’t much good if your child isn’t saving in the first place because they can’t deposit bills or because they dislike the experience of looking at their piggy bank.
How do I teach my child good financial habits using a piggy bank?
Teaching your child to use the piggy bank is one and the same with teaching them how to be prudent with their savings.
In short, piggy banks give your child several experiences which are helpful when it comes to building good financial habits, including:
- Forgoing immediate rewards
- Providing a measure of momentum regarding stored effort
- Reaping the long-awaited rewards of careful saving
When your child contributes to their piggy bank, they must make the conscious choice to give up something that they have in their hand today. This lesson is very difficult, and it is one that can take a very long time to master.
But, when they deposit their money into the piggy bank, they’ll get a satisfying clink which will tell them that this wasn’t the first time that they decided to plan for their future.
And, as they make more and more contributions to their savings, your child will feel the piggy bank getting heavier and heavier. Eventually, when it’s time to make a withdrawal, your child will deeply appreciate all of the effort that they put in.
The chunk of money that your child withdraws from their piggy bank is not something that they could have created if they hadn’t prudently saved over time. Most children immediately recognize this, and it’s this payout which makes piggy banks such a useful tool.
Should children be able to make withdrawals without breaking their piggy bank?
The question of whether children should be able to withdraw from their piggy bank without breaking it or asking an adult for help is a contentious one.
There are arguments for both approaches. In real life, your child will be able to withdraw from their savings whenever they need to. This means that their savings will always be within reach, much like a piggy bank that allows withdrawals.
On the other hand, many people can’t resist the money within reach, and children are no different. Because children may not have enough structure to avoid dipping into their savings, they may not fully appreciate the lesson that the piggy bank is designed to teach.
So, the choice is yours whether your child should be able to withdraw their savings easily or whether it should be difficult in the name of education.
Younger children will probably do better than older children with a withdrawal-capable piggy bank because they are more prone to listen to what parents tell them, however.
When should children get their first piggy bank?
The best age for a child to get a piggy bank is whenever they are old enough to appreciate the lesson. For many children, age 5 is a good starting point. The most important thing is that you teach your child lessons with the piggy bank consistently over time.
This means that if you buy your child a piggy bank at age 5, you might be teaching them how to save with it until age 8 or 9. It’s up to you when you stop your lessons and cash out.
Older children probably don’t need to have their piggy bank replaced with a newer model. Instead, you should move on to teaching your older children more complex finance lessons after they have mastered the basics that the piggy bank provides.