The Top 6 Best Baby Dolls for Girls – New 2019 Edition

Best Baby DollsA baby doll is more than a toy. For many children, a baby doll is also their first friend. There are certainly no shortage of baby dolls available, but the variety can also be confusing when buying one for your child.

The best baby dolls are safe, affordable, durable and have characteristics which the child connects with in some way. Our complete guide to the best baby dolls for 2019 starts now:

Our #1 Choice
Adora PlayTime Baby Boy Doll, Little Prince, Washable Toy Doll with Soft...
Our #2 Choice
American Girl WellieWishers Camille Doll
Our #3 Choice
Cabbage Patch Kids Cuties Collection, Parker the Puppy Cutie Baby Doll
Adora PlayTime Baby Boy Doll, Little Prince, Washable Toy Doll with Soft...
American Girl WellieWishers Camille Doll
Cabbage Patch Kids Cuties Collection, Parker the Puppy Cutie Baby Doll
Price not available
Our #1 Choice
Adora PlayTime Baby Boy Doll, Little Prince, Washable Toy Doll with Soft...
Adora PlayTime Baby Boy Doll, Little Prince, Washable Toy Doll with Soft...
Price not available
Our #2 Choice
American Girl WellieWishers Camille Doll
American Girl WellieWishers Camille Doll
Our #3 Choice
Cabbage Patch Kids Cuties Collection, Parker the Puppy Cutie Baby Doll
Cabbage Patch Kids Cuties Collection, Parker the Puppy Cutie Baby Doll

Circle number 1 Top Pick

Adora Playtime Baby Doll Little Prince

Soft, cuddly and small, the Little Prince is a great first doll for young ones.


  • Soft, portable baby doll
  • Includes removable onesie and baby bottle
  • Realistic face with closeable eyes
  • Variety of playtime accessories available


  • Might be a bit too basic for older kids

Soft and cuddly, the Little Prince is a great companion for young children one year or older. This 13-inch baby doll is small enough for little hands to hold onto and cuddle with. With a weighted bean bag bottom, the Little Prince can sit upright, too.

Completely washable, this doll has brown eyes which close. He even has a fresh baby powder scent. Includes a baby bottle (and he can also suck his thumb).

The Little Prince contains no harmful chemicals. Soft and safe, the Little Prince is a fun friend for younger kids.

Circle number2

American Girl Wellie Wishers Doll

The beautiful American Girl Dolls are always a favorite among both kids and adults.


  • Gorgeous, high-quality American Girl construction
  • Unique themes represent a variety of interests
  • Huge selection of clothing and accessories


  • Relatively expensive

Always popular, there are few different types of American Girl dolls to choose from. The WellieWishers are a group of characters who are all friends. Each doll has a theme and backstory. For instance, Camille loves the ocean which is reflected in the color of her eyes and clothing.

Custom American Girl Dolls can also be created. They can look like your child or however else you choose. Another popular option is the American Girl Doll of the Year, a series of dolls who each deal with different problems relevant to today.

Circle number3

Cabbage Patch Kids

Popular for over 30 years, the Cabbage Patch Kids are a classic for a reason.


  • A classic favorite for decades
  • Soft and durable
  • Practically unlimited style options


  • Only the Baby So Real line supports an app

The classic, cuddly Cabbage Patch kids you might have grown up with are still going strong today. Like the American Girl Dolls, there are a few different types of Cabbage Patch Kids. The Cabbage Patch Baby So Real has a life-like look with interactive feeding, burping and tickling. The Farm Friend Cuties are dressed like cute farm animals and pets.

All Cabbage Patch Kids include adoption papers, birthday and a name. As you might expect, a huge collection of accessories and clothing has been created over the years for these dolls. They’ve been a favorite of kids for decades.

Circle number4

Baby Alive Baby Go Bye Bye

Baby Alive is a highly interactive doll who crawls, speaks and even wets her diaper.


  • Wide range of realistic behavior
  • Rooted, brushable hair
  • Speaks both English and Spanish


  • Capable of crawling away if child is inattentive

Baby Go Bye Bye is ready for action. She crawls across the floor and will actually move towards the sound of her rattle. She’ll also talk, laugh and make other noises. If you give her a bottle, she’ll wet her diaper.

While changing diapers probably doesn’t sound like a fun activity for an adult, many kids love a doll which is this “alive.” Imitating parental roles is an important part of child development. Baby Go Bye Bye helps develop empathy and experience nurturing.

Baby Go Bye Bye includes a bottle, diaper, rattle, carrier, brush and more. Requires 4 AA batteries. A variety of different looks and themes are available from Baby Alive.

Circle number5

Breyer Spirit and Lucky Gift Set

Posable Lucky doll and her horse Spirit. Great for fans of the movie or just fans of horses.


  • Characters from Spirit Riding Free
  • Rideable horse
  • Brushable main and tail


  • Spirit is more detailed than Lucky

Lucky and her horse Spirit are the stars of DreamWorks’ Spirit Riding Free. This doll is made by Breyer, a very well-known manufacturer of model horses. This set includes a 5.75 inch tall Lucky, who can ride on the eight-inch tall Spirit.

Lucky is wearing her same outfit from the movie. But the real fan-favorite here is Spirit. An included brush lets the child style Spirit’s mane and tail. Great for fans of the movie or just fans of horses.

Circle number6

Melissa & Doug Mine to Love Baby Dolls

Realistic doll which helps young children learn about daily needs.


  • Helps with toilet training
  • Child can easily relate to doll
  • Teaches empathy
  • Fully poseable with closing eyes


  • Entirely hard plastic

Melissa & Doug’s line of Mine to Love dolls require a lot of care and attention. They fuss, drink from a bottle and even use the toilet. Unlike many other “wet” dolls, these dolls also go #2 in a potty chair.

Dolls who go to the bathroom, eat and fuss can play an important role in child development. Young kids relate to these dolls because they go through the same daily rituals. Taking care of the doll helps the child learn what actions are expected of them regarding eating, using the potty and so on.

Each 12” doll in the Mine to Love category includes a pacifier, bottle and self-stick diaper. Dolls are also fully poseable.


Best Baby Dolls FAQ

Finding the right doll for your child isn’t always easy. There are a lot of options out there, and doll shopping can quickly feel overwhelming. The best way to find the perfect doll for your kids is to narrow down your choices before you actually start shopping. Here are some common questions to ask yourself when searching for the best baby doll:

What Age is the Doll Appropriate For?

Children who are just a year or two old don’t want, or even understand, complicated features on a doll. They just want a soft doll they can easily carry. When shopping for a very young child, pay close attention to the size and feel of the doll. You’re looking for a doll your child can easily hold and snuggle.

As kids get older, they’ll want dolls which do more. By the time they’re in elementary school, kids are generally more interested in playing with dolls as a way to roleplay parenting. They’ll want a doll which acts more a real baby. This is a good age to introduce dolls which crawl, speak and otherwise move.

Dolls for kids under six will have relatively shapeless bodies filled with soft substances. However, most kids over the age of six start to show an interest in dolls made of plastic or similar materials. These dolls typically have fully poseable limbs and joints. Older kids often have fun posing their dolls.

How Do I Know if the Doll is Safe?

Safety is obviously a huge priority when selecting a doll. Be aware that just because a doll is soft and clean doesn’t necessarily means its safe. You’ll want to carefully check out any doll for potential safety problems.

Only buy a doll when you know what it’s made of. This is especially important for any filling materials used inside the doll. Kids, especially young ones, have a tendency to throws dolls around and otherwise bang them up a bit. Any material inside the doll has a potential to wind up on the outside. Make sure those materials are non-toxic and safe.

You also want to consider how the doll can potentially fall apart. For example, if the doll’s arm becomes disconnected, is it small enough to be a choking hazard? Don’t just consider the doll as a whole unit. Instead picture the size of any pieces it could be broken down into.

What Type of Hair Should the Doll Have?

Many kids, especially girls, focus on their doll’s hair. Dolls are a fun way for kids to learn about hair styling. There are two different types of doll hair: Rooted and wigged.

Rooted hair is secured to the inside of the doll’s hair. Tufts of hair emerge from small holes in the scalp. This type of doll hair is rugged and washable. The child can brush it roughly, wash it with shampoo and pretty much do whatever else they like without worrying about damage. Rooted hair does have style limitations and doesn’t look very natural.

Wigged hair allows for a variety of style options such as parts, fringe and more. The hair is knitted by hand to a mesh weave, which is then glued to the doll’s head. Wigged hair shouldn’t be washed. This type of hair often looks very beautiful but is best for older kids who know how to properly care for it.

What Type of Eyes Should the Doll Have?

Eyes add a lot of personality to a doll. There are two different types of doll eyes. They can either be fixed, where they are always open, or they can close at times, either by hand or by tipping the doll. Closing eyes tend to look more realistic, but dolls with closing eyes are usually more expensive.

Should My Child Have a Doll Which Looks Like Him or Her?

Absolutely. Great strides in diversity have been made in the doll industry over the years. No matter what your child looks like, you’ll likely be able to find a doll which resembles her or him. There’s no harm in buying a doll which looks like your child. In fact, it can often promote self-esteem and self-acceptance.

Of course, your child isn’t required to have a doll which looks like him or her. Many kids will choose a doll which looks nothing like them. There’s no harm with this, either. Kids can learn empathy and how to embrace differences.

Why Should Kids Play with Dolls?

Playing with dolls can have many benefits for both boys and girls. Dolls help kids develop their creativity and imaginations. The child can create make-believe worlds and imaginary stores for their dolls to be involved in. Dolls also helps kids understand the roles of other people such as mommy and daddy.

Also, dolls help kids develop communication skills. Children feel comfortable talking to their dolls, which is great practice for real-world interactions. Plus, dolls which speak help kids learn new words.

Dolls also help improve fine motor skills. Dressing the dolls and combing their hair helps tiny fingers learn to perform intricate movements. Many skills, such as buttoning clothing, are easier to first learn on a doll.

Finally, dolls help children develop empathy. Caring for a doll, especially one of the more interactive types, helps kids understand how others can feel hungry, uncomfortable or upset. Dolls helps kids learn to consider the feelings of other people.

All in All

A doll is often a beloved toy which a child will cherish for many years, even while other interests come and go. Selecting a doll can be a big responsibility. The best dolls are age-appropriate, safe and connect with the child on a deep level. Dolls helps kids learn communication skills, empathy and much more. Using the guide above, you can find the perfect doll for any age and interest.

Brett Gordon

Brett is the brains behind The Toy Report. Having clocked tons of time in toys research and online resource development, today, he’s dedicated to making The Toy Report a trusted space in the world of toys.